Matrix performance section

From Linux NFS

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(→Comparison of NFSv4 vs. NFSv3 for common use cases)
(→Evaluation in various load scenarios)
Line 225: Line 225:
|'''In progress'''
|'''In progress'''
|Bull
|Bull
-
|While most NFS functionnalities are not affected by the number of files (1 000 000 of empty files), some shell  functions are not responding : ls (answer take more than 15 hours). This question will be splited in sub topics soon.
+
|While most NFS functionnalities are not affected by the number of files (2 000 000 of empty files), some shell  functions are not responding : ls (answer take more than 15 hours). This question will be splited in sub topics soon.
 +
|-
 +
|IV.E.1.1
 +
|Test performance with large numbers of small (<4k) files - stat function ; empty files  -
 +
|addhoc tool
 +
|'''Done'''
 +
|Bull
 +
|Stat answer is O(n²). More details [http://nfsv4.bullopensource.org/tools/tests/page19.php here]
 +
|-
 +
|IV.E.1.2
 +
|Test performance with large numbers of small (<4k) files - Open function ; empty files -
 +
|addhoc tool
 +
|'''Near done'''
 +
|Bull
 +
|Open function is O(n). There is a bottle neck for n=1620000. More details [http://nfsv4.bullopensource.org/tools/tests/page20.php here]. Comparisons with [http://nfsv4.bullopensource.org/tools/tests/page21.php local file system] and [http://nfsv4.bullopensource.org/tools/tests/page22.php NFSv3].
|-
|-
|IV.E.2
|IV.E.2

Revision as of 12:32, 23 June 2005

Contents

Comparison of NFSv4 vs. NFSv3 for common use cases

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.A.1 Time to perform sequence of unique read/write operations Iozone Open Bull Done by Bull in 2004
IV.A.2 Time to perform sequence of cacheable read/write operations Iozone New
IV.A.3 Random reads/writes/opens from many clients to one server Iozone Open Bull Done by Bull in 2004
IV.A.4 Industry standard loads SpecSFS, Specweb99 New Tools does not exist.
IV.A.5 Time to read file from beginning to end and then rewrite it IOzone In progress Bull Part of IOZone standard tests
IV.A.6 Time for appending info to a log file sporadically over time Iozone New Bull
IV.A.7 Metadata - open/close intensive workload Iozone New Bull
IV.A.8 Metadata - directory scanning Iozone Done Bull Directory scanning over NFSv4 is analysed here. Time to stat a directory is O(n²) where n is the number of files in the directory.
IV.A.9 Metadata - create/delete Iozone New Bull
IV.A.10 Metadata - changing attributes (chown, chmod) while dir scanning IOZone New Bull
IV.A.11 How many locks can be made and released over time FFsB New Bull
IV.A.12 Comparison of speeds attainable for different NIC cards

NFSv4 on TCP vs. RDMA

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.B Compare latency, throughput, etc. of NFSv4 on TCP vs. RDMA New Only prototypes exist currently; possibly will be more fully implemented by end of 2005

Test performance on different local filesystems

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.C.1 Analyze whether file system choice affects performance Iozone Done Bull NFSv4 performances do not depend on the local file-system used
IV.C.2 Test performance with Ext2 on server with metadata /acls IOZone/FFsB
IV.C.3 Test performance with ext3 on server with metadata / acls IOZone/FFsB New
IV.C.4 Test performance with Reiser3 on server with metadata / acls IOZone/FFsB New
IV.C.5 Test performance with xfs on server with metadata / acls IOZone/FFsB New
IV.C.6 Test performance with jfs on server with metadata / acls IOZone/FFsB New
IV.C.7 Test performance with Reiser4 on server with metadata /acls IOZone/FFsB New

Test perfomance on different cluster filesystems

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.D.1 Test performance when using GFS cluster file system New
IV.D.2 Test performance when using Luster cluster file system New
IV.D.3 Test performance when using GPFS cluster file system New
IV.D.4 Test performance when using Polyserve cluster file system New

Evaluation in various load scenarios

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.E.1 Test performance with large numbers of small (<4k) files addhoc tool In progress Bull While most NFS functionnalities are not affected by the number of files (2 000 000 of empty files), some shell functions are not responding : ls (answer take more than 15 hours). This question will be splited in sub topics soon.
IV.E.1.1 Test performance with large numbers of small (<4k) files - stat function ; empty files - addhoc tool Done Bull Stat answer is O(n²). More details here
IV.E.1.2 Test performance with large numbers of small (<4k) files - Open function ; empty files - addhoc tool Near done Bull Open function is O(n). There is a bottle neck for n=1620000. More details here. Comparisons with local file system and NFSv3.
IV.E.2 Test performance with a few very large (>1G) files IOzone Open Bull Goals need clarifications: are we manipulating files (acl/metadatas/moving...) or reading/writing files?
IV.E.3 4-16 clients generating high load on 1 server in lab environment Mail/user dir New Bull
IV.E.4 2000-5000 clients on 5-10 servers in production environment Clusters New NetApps
IV.E.5 NFS "Cluster" scenario with 1000+ clients and several servers Film industry, HPC or visualization workload New
IV.E.6 NFS front end with cluster backend; 100+ clients New
IV.E.7 Pure cluster; 100+ clients New

Evaluation in stress scenarios

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.F.1 Measure performance of server when in limited resource situations :
  • Low memory / heavy swap space usage
  • High inode count situations
New
IV.F.2 Measure performance of client when in limited resource situations :
  • Low memory / heavy swap space usage
  • Low/saturated network bandwidth
New
IV.F.3 Graceful failure mode New See Chuck for more info
IV.F.4 Measure memory/network/CPU efficiency of client for fixed workload IOzone - FFsB In progress Bull

Scalability (performance)

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.G. Verify server scalability with clients generating various basic requests (ACCESS, GETATTR, et al) Iozone New
IV.G.2 Verify server scalability with clients using compound requests Iozone New
IV.G.3 Measure effects of scaling up number of connections IOZone New Bull SMP - Measure number of mounts per second on client and server
IV.G.4 Measure effects of increasing number of files Addhoc tool Open Bull
IV.G.5 Measure effects of increasing file size (with/without cache) IOzone Open Bull
IV.G.6 Measure effects when increasing size of on-the-wire NFS read or write operations :
  • Mount options from the client side; find optimal settings
  • Measure for stable latency behavior
Iozone New
IV.G.7 Measure performance when scaling CPU count per node on SMP&NUMA Iozone New
IV.G.8 Measure performance when scaling memory per node on SMP&NUMA Iozone New
IV.G.9 Measure performance when scaling NIC count per node Iozone New
IV.G.10 Measure performance when scaling disk count per node Iozone New


Identify best practices for performance tuning

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.H Identify best practices for performance tuning:
  • --- Auto-tuning for max performance during installation?
  • Tuning NFS transfer size
  • Details will need to be captured as we complete other testing
New Bull Not clear. There is few tunables points on NFSv4.

Performance effects of security features

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.J.1 Measure performance when operating with IPSec integrity and privacy IOzone New
IV.J.2 Measure performance when operating with Kerberos 5 integrity and privacy IOzone New
IV.J.3 Measure performance when operating with SPKM integrity and privacy IOzone New
IV.J.4 Measure performance when operating with Lipkey integrity and privacy IOzone New

Performances over Internet

ID test tool test status owner notes
IV.K.1 Measure performances for various fixed workoads over WAN Iozone - FFsB Open Bull - CITI Tests between CITI and Bull
IV.K.2 Measure performances for various fixed workoads with Kerberos enabled over WAN Iozone - FFsB Open Bull - CITI Tests between CITI and Bull
IV.K.3 Measure performances for metadata manipulation over WAN (directory lookup, attributes manipulations ...) FFsB Open Bull - CITI Tests between CITI and Bull
Retrieved from "http://wiki.linux-nfs.org/wiki/index.php/Matrix_performance_section"
Personal tools